[Stc_presidents-discuss] New CAA Guidelines

marsha.jennerjohn at schneider-electric.com marsha.jennerjohn at schneider-electric.com
Wed Jul 22 17:56:48 UTC 2015

Since the Eastern Iowa Chapter year runs June to May, we do not have plans 
for the second half of a year until July.
New officers are elected in May, we have meetings in June and July (when 
there are no chapter meetings) and make plans for the chapter for the 
Sept-May period. So we do not have a "2015 plan" we have a  "2015/2016 

And when your chapter has less than 25 members, doing a regional 
conference is out of the question.  We don't have the people or the cash 
reserves to do something like that. 


Marsha Jennerjohn  |   Schneider Electric   |  Partner Business  |   
United States  |   Senior Technical Writer 
Phone: +1-319-369-6322  |   Mobile: +1-319-431-7089 
Email: marsha.jennerjohn at schneider-electric.com  |   Site: 
www.schneider-electric.com  |   Address: 3700 Sixth St. SW, Cedar Rapids, 
IA 52404 USA 

*** Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail 

From:   Kim Rosenlof <Kim at aeroink.com>
To:     "stc_presidents-discuss at mailer.stc.org" 
<stc_presidents-discuss at mailer.stc.org>, 
Date:   07/22/2015 12:29 PM
Subject:        Re: [Stc_presidents-discuss] New CAA Guidelines
Sent by:        stc_presidents-discuss-bounces at mailer.stc.org

I agree with many of Debra?s statements.  I think it?s a little cheeky of 
the committee to release the new CAA guidelines as 2015 guidelines. 
Wouldn't it be a little more fair to keep the 2014 guidelines for 2015 and 
release these new guidelines as the 2016 guidelines? 

That being said, the one thing that caught me off guard is that one of the 
Required Activities is to ?Submit your general plan of yearly activities 
for the upcoming year [required of all communities].? Has anyone else done 
this for 2015?  How was this submitted, and to whom? 


Kim Rosenlof, President
Society for Technical Communication Phoenix Chapter
480-710-8830 ? www.stc-phoenix.com

From: <Johnson>, Debra <Debra.Johnson at wyn.com>
Date: Tuesday, July 21, 2015 at 8:32 PM
To: "stc_presidents-discuss at mailer.stc.org" <
stc_presidents-discuss at mailer.stc.org>
Subject: [Stc_presidents-discuss] New CAA Guidelines

Hello Fellow STC Presidents,
As some of you know, the Community Achievement Awards Evaluating Committee 
just released its latest CAA application and guidelines. Unlike previous 
updates, this one is a total revamp.
Have any of you had a chance to review the new application and think about 
whether your community will be applying for an award this year? 
What are your thoughts on the achievability of the new requirements? We 
would love to know?
Our chapter, Orlando Central Florida, bases our chapter activities and 
initiatives to a large extent on the requirements for the CAA, since 
according to STC, these are the activities in which communities should be 
engaging. To this point in the year, we have been working to the previous 
year?s guidelines as the revamp was not available.
Our Administrative Council discussed the revamped guidelines and believe 
that with so many new requirements, the deletion of many activities that 
have long been key CAA criteria, the inherent inflexibility of the system 
(?either you do it or you don?t? with no substitutions and only two Bonus 
options), and a completely new scoring system that has raised the bar 
significantly, communities will be hard pressed to achieve the goals set 
by the CAA committee within the time remaining in 2015.
We did an item-for-item analysis of the new criteria and projected how our 
community would stack up against them. We determined that if we did all 
the things we did last year to earn our community achievement award, we 
would not qualify for an award under the new system. 
One reason for this is the requirements were apparently established for a 
12-month period but the documents were not posted this yearuntil nearly 
summertime, and summer is when many chapters go on hiatus. There isn?t a 
full year?s worth of time to pull off the number of new activities needed 
to win recognition. For all practical purposes, communities have four 
months to adjust.
An example of this is, several activities (both new and carry-overs from 
previous years? guidelines) are now scored on a sliding scale heavily 
weighted towards how many times the activity occurs during the year. 
Particularly with new activities, which communities were not aware of and 
may not have been pursuing, with just a few months left in the year it?s 
not feasible to achieve full points for them. 
In addition, and in a surprise move(?at least to us) , there is heavy 
emphasis on regional conferences, so much so that communities who do not 
sponsor one of these conferences are at a tremendous disadvantage. They 
lose 5 points?that?s 5 out of the baseline total of 83.  Since a Platinum 
Award requires 90% of the possible points, you can only lose 8.3 points 
and qualify for it. Thus for all intents and purposes, if you don?t 
sponsor a regional conference, you can?t earn a Platinum Award. 
Do you think this was the committee?s intent?  If so, should they consider 
the fact that smaller communities may nothave the person-power to work at 
regional conferences, nor the financial resources to organize and run them
?  In the interest of fairness, we feel the five points for a regional 
conference should be moved to the Bonus category, and not be part of the 
baseline ?required? criteria.
?and there are many such examples.
We were wondering what you think? So would you be so kind as to answer a 
few questions for us as a fellow community?
1.       If you have submitted CAA applications in the past, were you 
intending to do so for 2015?
2.       Has the new application changed your mind about applying?
3.       Please comment on the application: Do you believe it?s a fair way 
to assess the strength of a community?s activities? Specifically, how do 
you think your community will fare under the new guidelines?
4.       Would your community support an appeal to the CAAEC and the Board 
(if necessary) to revise the scoring in order to take into consideration 
the late release of the point assignments as well as to ?level the playing 
field? to account for community size and financial resources?
Thanks for your input!
Society for Technical Communication ? Orlando Central Florida Chapter 
Debra D. Johnson 
Technical Communication Lead | Information Technology Services | Knowledge 
Management  | Content Strategy | Information Development,  Delivery, and 
Wyndham Vacation Ownership
6277 Sea Harbor Drive
Orlando, FL 32821 
Office: (407) 626-4428
Cell 407-212-0963
debra.johnson at wyn.com
"The information in this electronic mail ("e-mail") message may contain 
information that is confidential and/or privileged, or may otherwise be 
protected by work product or other legal rules. It is solely for the use 
of the individual(s) or the entity(ies) originally intended. Access to 
this electronic mail message by anyone else is unauthorized. If you are 
not the intended recipient, be advised that any unauthorized review, 
disclosure, copying, distribution or use of this information, or any 
action taken or omitted to be taken in reliance on it, is prohibited and 
may be unlawful. Please notify the sender immediately if you have received 
this electronic message by mistake, and destroy all copies of the original 

"The sender believes that this e-mail and any attachments were free of any 
virus, worm, Trojan horse, malicious code and/or other contaminants when 
sent. E-mail transmissions cannot be guaranteed to be secure or 
error-free, so this message and its attachments could have been infected, 
corrupted or made incomplete during transmission. By reading the message 
and opening any attachments, the recipient accepts full responsibility for 
any viruses or other defects that may arise, and for taking remedial 
action relating to such viruses and other defects. Neither Wyndham 
Worldwide Corporation nor any of its affiliated entities is liable for any 
loss or damage arising in any way from, or for errors or omissions in the 
contents of, this message or its attachments."

Wyndham may monitor all incoming and outgoing email communications, 
including the content of emails and attachments, for purposes of security, 
legal compliance, training, quality assurance and other purposes permitted 
by law.

This email has been scanned by the Symantec Email Security.cloud service.
Stc_presidents-discuss mailing list
Stc_presidents-discuss at mailer.stc.org

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mailer.stc.org/pipermail/stc_presidents-discuss/attachments/20150722/f0271282/attachment-0001.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: image/png
Size: 15380 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://mailer.stc.org/pipermail/stc_presidents-discuss/attachments/20150722/f0271282/attachment-0001.png>

More information about the Stc_presidents-discuss mailing list